Westward Independent

Exposing Bias: City News Skews Perception with Selective NDP Headlines

by Joseph Enslow
1 comment

Headline Hokey-Pokey: A City News Special

“BC NDP remains top choice among voters: poll,” blares the headline from City News, a beacon of selective storytelling in a sea of nuanced news. This gem of a title, shared far and wide, paints a rosy picture of unanimous support for BC’s New Democratic Party ahead of an October election. Yet, delve a smidge below this gleaming surface, and the waters muddy with the complexities and contradictions the headline deftly skips.

See their article here:

BC NDP remains top choice among voters: poll

Breaking Down the Not-So-Subtle Bias

Let’s dissect, shall we? The article, penned by Pippa Norman, reveals a tangled web of voter sentiment that somehow didn’t make the headline cut. For starters, it notes, “those polled still reported their unhappiness with the NDP government’s recent performance, giving it a ‘poor job’ rating on top issues like health care, cost of living, and housing.” Ah, but why let a bit of widespread dissatisfaction cloud a perfectly good headline?

And then there’s this nugget: “However, when it comes to public safety and climate change, voters believe none of the major political parties will do a good job.” One might think that such a damning indictment of political impotence across the board would be headline-worthy. But no, the melodrama of collective incompetence lacks the zing of unilateral support, it seems.

The pièce de résistance? “Slightly more than half of those surveyed said they’re supporting a party because they truly believe in it, while the other half said they’re only supporting a party because of their distaste for the others.” The romance of democracy in action — choosing the least objectionable option as if sifting through a bargain bin of slightly damaged goods. Surely, that’s headline material? Alas, it appears not.

Alternative Headlines You Won’t See

In the spirit of fairness (and because we’re all about giving credit where credit is overdue), let’s propose a few headlines that City News might have considered if nuance hadn’t been on holiday:

  • “BC Voters Grudgingly Rally Behind NDP Amidst Broader Discontent”
  • “Public Safety and Climate Change: BC’s Political Bermuda Triangle”
  • “NDP Tops Polls by Default in a Sea of Voter Disenchantment”

Each of these alternatives presents a facet of the story that was overshadowed by the chosen headline, inviting readers to engage with the complexity of voter sentiment and political landscape in BC.

Shame on You, City News

The recently released 2023 Edelman Trust Barometer underscores the critical role of traditional news media as a trusted source, with Canada standing out for its higher trust levels in traditional media compared to the global average. In light of these findings, the responsibility of media outlets like City News to uphold the principles of accuracy, fairness, and impartiality cannot be overstated. It’s a matter of public trust, and when headlines fail to reflect the full story, they betray that trust.

The Barometer’s insights also reveal a society grappling with polarization and a desire for businesses—and by extension, media—to act as beacons of truth. In this context, City News’ selective headline not only misses the mark but also contributes to the very polarization it’s implicitly tasked to mitigate.

In an era marked by skepticism towards media sources, the onus is on outlets like City News to foster trust through unbiased and comprehensive reporting. The choice of a headline should not serve as a vehicle for veiled endorsements or subtle biases but as an entry point to informed, balanced discourse.

As readers navigate an increasingly complex information landscape, their reliance on media outlets to provide clear, unbiased, and comprehensive coverage is paramount. The case of City News and its coverage of the BC NDP highlights a broader challenge facing the media industry: the need to reconcile the demands of attention-grabbing headlines with the ethical imperatives of truthful reporting. It’s high time for media outlets to embrace their role as pillars of democracy, ensuring that their headlines—and the stories that follow—accurately reflect the world in all its complexity.

You may also like

1 comment

Linda Robertson March 23, 2024 - 11:21 am

Re: A Headline Hokey-Pokey. A City News Special.
Thankyou so very much for your article chastising City News biased report.
It use to be that we could rely on unbiased reporting. Not so any longer. Unless one starts hunting for the independent sources that, hopefully, haven’t been arrested and thrown in jail for asking a question or speaking the truth.


Leave a Comment

As a dedicated grassroots newspaper, we unearth exclusive valley stories and events that remain hidden elsewhere. With passion and fearlessness, we expose what happens behind closed doors, giving you a sneak peek into the heart of our community. Experience the pulse of our valley like never before. Welcome to a newspaper that punches above its weight, where local voices come alive with every turn of the page.

©2024 All rights reserved. Designed and Developed by WWIND.